For coaches
Should youth soccer coaches yell at players?
Coaches should not scream at kids. But can they ever raise their voice? Youth coaches and a sports psychologist on yelling, raising your voice and giving instructions from the sideline.
· 3 min read · FC.APP Team
Coaches should not scream at kids. Some people say a coach who does should lose their license. But can a coach ever raise their voice?
Screaming and raising your voice are not the same thing. A “coach” who keeps yelling at players, criticizing them and pointing out every mistake out loud is very different from a coach who wants to fire up the team. How do coaches see it? We asked them.
What coaches say
A coach should teach, not train animals, and above all a coach is an educator. As an educator, I think we sometimes have to raise our voice. When we can fire up the boys or girls in a positive way, build them up, or wake up a team that is not quite there that day, we can raise our voice. But never when kids make mistakes. That is not the way.
I think coaches can sometimes raise their voice, but it depends on the situation. Your voice is one of a coach's tools, so you should use it. There is a big difference between mindless yelling at kids and calling their attention to something.
I agree that a lot depends on the situation. With kids, raising your voice should be a one-time signal, like an alarm bell to get the players' attention. If the message is for the whole team, not one player, if it is not a judgment, if it helps the team and is not overused, then a coach can raise their voice. The younger the age group, the calmer your tone should be. I won't say coaches must never raise their voice, but it can never be a message that hurts a player.
What a sports psychologist says
Dominik Bialic, a sports psychologist who works with youth academies, sees it a bit differently. Even when a coach means well and wants to help the team, some players may take it in a completely different way.
People sometimes play down yelling and say they “only” raised their voice. Society is changing, and kids are different too. One kid may not react at all to a shout of “Focus!”, while for another, a raised voice can cause fear. Research on raised voices and yelling shows clearly that it does not help, especially with kids, and it can backfire. If we raise our voice too often, kids can become anxious. My view is that there are plenty of other methods that can have a positive effect.
What about instructions from the sideline?
So much for raising your voice to motivate players. What about calling out instructions? Is it wrong for a coach to yell to a defender that an opponent is coming from behind?
I am not a fan of sideline instructions. At our academy, if we call anything out, it never contains the decision. The decision always stays with the player. It is like helping a student with homework. Guiding them is great, but writing the answers for them only helps in the moment. It is the same on the field.
Yelling “Watch out!” or “Man on!” is not a great option. If we want to prepare a player for a higher level, we should build a practice environment where he learns to check over his shoulder before he gets the ball. I stay away from telling players what to do. Coaches should not yell at players, and they should not tell them to pass, shoot or dribble either. Have I ever raised my voice with my players? Yes. Say we are on a small field and get a 3v2 we practiced that week. I just yell “3v2!”, and the boys read the play and decide on their own whether to dribble, pass or shoot.
The bottom line
Coaches can raise their voice in certain moments, but they have to do it with thought. They need to stay aware so they do not make young players afraid. Coaches should not yell instructions at players, even with good intentions. Boys and girls need to make their own decisions. Steering them from the sideline does not lead anywhere good.
Want to motivate players without raising your voice? In FC.APP, you can give players badges for progress and effort and share the work with your assistant coaches. See FC.APP for coaches.
Tournaments, scrimmages and player motivation in one app. Free for coaches.
