Skip to content
FC.APP
← All articles

For organizers

Participation medals for every player: for or against?

Should only the winners get medals and trophies at a youth soccer tournament? Sports psychologists on participation medals, individual awards and sportsmanship awards.

· 5 min read · FC.APP Team

A soccer tournament is about the games, but it is also about the awards ceremony at the end, where the winners get medals and trophies. Have you ever wondered if that is a good way to raise kids through sports? Could it be one of the reasons kids quit? Would it be better to give every player the same medal? And should individual awards include more than “MVP” and “top scorer”?

Almost every competition ends the same way: medals, trophies and awards for the top teams. For adults, that feels natural. Awards match the place you finished. But is that the message we want to teach 8- and 10-year-olds?

I think that up to age 12, every kid at a tournament should get a medal, an award or a certificate. Competition is a very important part of sports, but it should come when a kid starts to specialize. That is when I would bring in different medal colors, trophy sizes and individual awards, because they motivate young athletes to keep working. Every athlete wants trophies and medals. Age matters, though. With the youngest kids, the goal is to get them moving, and awards for taking part can do that.

Karolina Chlebosz, sports psychologist

Kids need awards less than adults think

As usual in psychology, there is no single answer, so it helps to look at a few points of view. From a sports angle, think of the joy of players lifting the Champions League trophy. It is probably the biggest moment of their careers, and they remember it for life. Medals and trophies matter a lot to athletes. But that is professional adult sports.

The need for outside rewards matters more to adults than to kids. It is not a main need for young children. Kids play sports mostly because playing soccer is fun.

Konrad Czapeczka and Rafal Malinowski, sports psychologists

From that point of view, awards for kids can be adults bringing their own needs into a kids' world, where thinking works differently. Adults can quickly teach kids that success means getting a prize. Self-determination theory, from psychologists Deci and Ryan, adds another view: adults can grow a kid's natural drive by meeting three basic needs. Autonomy (letting kids make decisions and take responsibility), competence (noticing and praising progress) and relatedness (showing care and interest).

So would it be a better idea to give every player the same keepsake medal, and give a trophy only to the winning team? At Poland's largest kids' tournament, with local, regional and national rounds, every player at every stage gets the same medal.

The joy kids get from moving is hugely important. I am not a fan of punishments and rewards. I do not think prizes, trophies, medals or toys are necessary for a child. Later on, they are a nice keepsake and a reason to keep improving. For kids, the fun of being active should come first. So I would neither reward nor punish movement.

Karolina Chlebosz

In my opinion, every kid should get a keepsake for playing in a tournament. It can be a medal, because a medal clearly says “sports.” As a kid, I went to many national and international tournaments, and it was always great to bring home a medal that reminded me of the effort it took to get there. A medal is not only about the result. It stands for all the work and progress.

Konrad Czapeczka

Individual awards: more than the top scorer

Individual awards have usually been one-dimensional. They reward players who score a lot or make big saves: MVP, top scorer, top goalkeeper. What about other positions? What about kids who want to play center back? Can they never win an individual award? Could that discourage them?

Some tournaments now give an award for each part of the team: goalkeeper, defender, midfielder, forward and top scorer. I like that you can recognize a forward and the top scorer separately. Look at Karim Benzema in the years when Cristiano Ronaldo scored the most goals for Real Madrid. Benzema was their key striker, and he is a big reason Ronaldo scored so much. I would keep individual awards, but highlight every position and the whole team. Tournaments are won by defenders and midfielders too, not just forwards and goalkeepers.

Konrad Czapeczka

From a psychology point of view, I would not single out individuals in team sports at all. Soccer is about a team goal, not a personal one. If I had to give individual awards, I would cover every position, and I would skip them in the youngest age groups. In this sport, the team matters most. After a tournament, I would reward kids with kind words and praise.

Karolina Chlebosz

An even better option would be to recognize players for specific skills that help them develop, like keeping their head up while dribbling. Then kids would watch their own progress more closely, and it would not be about goals and assists. Counting that is hard, but one basketball coach found a way: kids on the bench each watch one teammate and count how many times he does one skill right. If that worked in other sports, kids would focus more on the joy of getting better.

Reward sportsmanship

Fair play is part of every sport, and you could argue it is the most important part. Every coach and parent should live by it, because we want to raise kids by the rules of fair play.

Teams often get a sportsmanship award for having the fewest yellow and red cards. Why not also give a youth tournament award to a player who showed respect for an opponent? Rewarding that kind of behavior would give other kids a role model.

Both psychologists agree. Chlebosz says sports should raise kids to be good people first and athletes second. Czapeczka adds that not every kid will play soccer for a living, and a sportsmanship award at every tournament, or even every game, would be a great way to back that up.

Awards and results in FC.APP

In FC.APP, you choose what your tournament shows. For the youngest age groups, you can play without scores or keep scores and standings hidden from participants. When you do keep score, goal tracking builds the top scorers list for you. See how FC.APP works for organizers.

So do kids really need gold, silver and bronze like at the Olympics? Should individual awards go only to the top scorer and the goalkeeper? Or does recognizing everyone clash with how you see sports, as a time for competition and battles on the field? What do you think?

Run your next tournament in FC.APP for free: team registration, the game schedule, live scores and standings in one app.

See FC.APP for organizers

See it in FC.APP

  • A format that fits your day

    Round robin, pool play, a bracket and combinations. You match the format to the number of teams, age and time.

  • Every goal has a scorer

    You assign a goal to a player from the list or by jersey number, or save it with no scorer. The top scorers list builds itself.

  • Standings that update themselves

    After every game, the standings and top scorers list are up to date for everyone. No paper and no calculator.