For parents
Is talent enough to make a career?
To make it as a pro soccer player, you need hard work, commitment and the right attitude. And a bit of talent helps. But is talent alone enough to reach the top?
· 4 min read · FC.APP Team
To become a professional soccer player, you need to work hard, stay committed and bring the right attitude to training and to the ball itself. It also helps to have a bit of talent. But is talent alone, without hard work, enough to get to the top?
Talent is usually described as a natural gift in an intellectual, physical or artistic area: being clearly better than average at something, or learning it unusually fast. In soccer, it is about more than one kid being better than another. Rafal Matusiak, who was director of coaching at the academy of the Polish club Jagiellonia Bialystok when we spoke, thinks so too. In his view, Polish soccer is not very good at spotting talent.
To me, talent is the ability to make decisions, in other words cognitive intelligence. Attitude, work ethic and the ability to learn matter a lot too. Those are the three most important things for me. At a given age you might be a bit stronger or faster, and that shows off your strengths and hides your weaknesses. But without the right work ethic, cognitive intelligence, decision-making under pressure and the ability to learn fast, I don't think you have talent.
Lionel Messi is the classic example of a talented player. He stood out from a very young age, and certainly not because of his size, which plays a big role in kids' soccer. Yet he won his Ballon d'Or awards because he worked hard for them. Can it be done any other way? We asked several coaches whether they had seen players with plenty of skill but the wrong attitude.
Of course I have. They don't play soccer anymore, even though they were very gifted. What they lacked was a talent for hard work.
There were a few players like that a dozen years ago, there are a few now, and I think there always will be. I don't know anyone with a completely careless approach who made it. I know players who were laid-back and very sure of themselves, but they never lacked determination and commitment to training and games.
I have seen it. About ten years ago there was a boy, not on my team, who at 16 was a key player for the national youth teams, and at 18 he just disappeared. He stopped playing soccer and quit sports altogether. Nothing was working for him: not his diet, not his attitude in practice, not his commitment.
Mario Balotelli and Radja Nainggolan never looked like players with a model attitude. If anything, they showed what not to do. Yet they, and not many far more disciplined players, played for top European clubs. And Ronaldinho, who was famously relaxed about his job, did magic with the ball.
The right attitude isn't only about work ethic, because you can work hard and get no joy from it. It all comes down to enjoying the game. When you went out to play as a kid, you did it for fun. I think we push kids to specialize too early, and many of them have lost that joy of the game. More and more, soccer feels like a duty to young players and less and less like fun.
So what if you are not the most talented, and kids your age are better than you? Is there a way? Have players who did not stand out as kids gone on to become great?
Not everyone has a talent for soccer. Most players probably don't. They just work hard for their success. Look at any team and you will find players who were not always the stars of their birth year and did not play for every youth national team, yet built international careers. The clearest proof is Robert Lewandowski, who did not play for Poland until the under-21 level. He shows that hard work can take you to the top. On the other hand, I have coached many players in Poland's top junior league who played for youth national teams regularly, and their careers ended. Making a youth national team or winning a national junior title is no guarantee of success.
Besides talent and hard work, you need luck and patience. Over ten games, a talented player will stand out in five or six of them, while a hard worker might stand out in one or two. The hard worker needs the luck that someone is watching in exactly those games and gives him a chance.
Kamil Piatkowski made the most of his chance. He started playing in his hometown of Jaslo, in southeastern Poland. His first coach remembered that he was not even the biggest star of the local club. But in one game between his regional U15 team and Poland's youth national team, he played so well that the top academies in the country came calling. He went to Zaglebie Lubin and did not break through there. Then Rakow Czestochowa gave him a chance, and in 2021 he moved to Red Bull Salzburg for a reported five million euros.
We have one piece of advice for each group. For the talented: do not rest on your gift, and do everything you can to make the most of it. For the hard workers: even if you are losing out to others today, keep believing that one day you will be the one calling the shots.
Follow the progress, not just the talent
Progress in youth soccer is easier to see over a whole season than in a single game. In FC.APP, parents can follow their child's games and see the Player Card with badges from the coach.
Your child's games, the Player Card and badges from the coach in one app.
