Skip to content
FC.APP
← All articles

For organizers

Do youth soccer tournaments need referees?

Are referees a must at tournaments for young kids, or do they mostly add stress? What coaches say, and what happens at games where the players make the calls.

· 4 min read · FC.APP Team

In professional soccer, a game without a referee is hard to imagine. But do referees belong at every tournament for young kids? Do they stress out beginners? And in the early years, could coaches, or even the players themselves, make the calls?

If you love the game, the question may sound strange at first. How do you play a soccer game without a referee? Even with one, there are arguments on the field. What would happen without one?

Youth soccer is a different game, though. For coaches and kids, what matters most is the fun of playing, a way to spend time with friends. When players are 5 to 11 years old, a pro career is a very long way off, and only a few will ever get there. So it is fair to ask: what is a referee for in the U6 to U10 age groups?

To control chaos on the field? To make kids respect authority? To call fouls and hand out cards? Ask those questions honestly, and a clear “yes, we need one” gets harder to defend.

What coaches say

Artur Hibner, a coach who works with preschoolers every day, told us that referees often stress kids out, and a stressed kid cannot enjoy the game. One of his sons plays in an age group without scores, but he also plays up with older kids in a league that keeps scores. His son says the referee makes him nervous, because he never knows if the ref will be strict and harsh. That made Hibner think that games without referees matter for kids.

Add the games where a referee makes mistakes. Coaches get upset on the sideline and show it, and the kids see all of it. That is a lot of stress at an age when there should be as little of it as possible. Soccer should be fun, not one more place where a kid feels uncomfortable.

In Poland, where these coaches work, the national federation stopped keeping scores and standings for under-11 players and moved those age groups to friendly tournaments, often with no referee at all.

When a referee is there, one coach or the other has a problem with some call. Without one, the kids decide. At that age they are still honest enough that nobody cheats. Coaches step in to stop rough play, and they make decisions that are good for the kids, not for their own team. Disputes are rare. When a kid commits a foul, he usually just steps back on his own. Is there a referee at practice? No. When there is no score, you do not need one.

Dawid Dominiczak, coach educator

I remember when coaches got really tense at kids' games if a goal came 10 seconds before the final whistle. Coaches ran up and down the sideline. Now it is relaxed, and nobody cares if a game ends a few seconds early or late. Parents used to pressure coaches too: “Why did you sub out your top players at 1-0? That is why we lost.” Now everyone plays equal time, and the kids are happy. That is what matters most.

Marcin Adamczak, vice president of a youth club, to a Polish youth soccer site

What a game without a referee looks like

A sports journalist who watched a tournament without referees said it reminded him of pickup games in the neighborhood. You can smile at the same arguments we all had as kids, like who gets the throw-in: “Our ball, you touched it last!” and “No, it came off you!”

There will always be disputes, even with a referee. Kids work it out fast and agree on who gets the restart.

At one game, two players were arguing about a throw-in. A third player ran over and told his own teammate that he had touched the ball last, so the other team got the throw-in. Problem solved in seconds.

That is how disputes were settled in pickup games, and a tournament without scores or standings is not far from pickup soccer. Years ago there were no academies for 4-year-olds. Many future pros joined a club in their early teens.

Nobody needed a referee in the backyard, and young kids do not really need one either. Referees are essential in professional soccer and very useful for older youth players. For the youngest kids, though, a referee is a stranger who can cause fear and stress.

Will kids learn the rules without a referee?

Coaches are there to teach the rules, and kids also learn from their parents and from games on TV. It is hard to find a strong argument that a referee is needed at every game for young kids. Respect for referees can be learned a bit later, just as it was decades ago.

This is not about referees being bad or unfair. Many referees are great with kids and know how to act on the field. Let's always look at the kids, not at our own goals and expectations. The kids play the game, and we only organize it for them. They need to feel comfortable.

Artur Hibner

Running a tournament with or without referees

FC.APP works both ways. For the youngest age groups, you can play without scores or keep scores and standings hidden from participants in the tournament format settings. For older age groups, you can invite referees who enter scores from their own phones, and live scores go straight into the standings. See how FC.APP works for organizers.

What do you think? Is a referee a must at tournaments for young kids? Did these arguments change your mind?

Run your next tournament in FC.APP for free: team registration, the game schedule, live scores and standings in one app.

See FC.APP for organizers

See it in FC.APP