Skip to content
FC.APP
← All articles

For coaches

Can a lopsided loss teach young players anything?

“I don't believe a player who loses 0-22 feels like coming to the next practice, knowing the same thing awaits him next week.” Youth coaches on whether lopsided losses have any upside.

· 4 min read · FC.APP Team

“I don't believe a player who loses 0-22 feels like coming to the next practice, knowing the exact same thing awaits him next week,” says Slawomir Ficek, who coached an under-19 team at the Polish club GTS Pruszcz Gdanski. Can losing all the time have any upside?

Plenty of people reading this played soccer as kids, and somewhere along the way something happened and we did not become world-class players. I remember that we lost our first league game 0-32, and I had the “honor” of playing in goal. One, two or three losses like that can happen. But if success means getting one shot on the other team's goal, soccer is not much fun.

Over the long run, say a whole half of the season, games like that make no sense. In single cases, they can. You also have to look at the bigger picture. In our case, younger boys played in the league, and in theory you could say it was a learning experience for them. But that learning is pretty thin if you spend 14 games chasing the ball. One or two defeats do no harm, and you can even test yourself. In the long run, though, I see more damage than benefit.

Jan Rygiel, youth coach at AS Progres Krakow

Teams struggle for many reasons. Not long before this article first ran, Pogon Szczecin dropped out of Poland's top U15 junior league, even though the club has one of the country's leading academies and draws talented boys from the whole region. The club bet on a younger group of players, who could not cope in such a physical league and moved down to the regional level, where they might be the ones running up the score.

As a youth coach, I think defeats like that do teach something: humility. Games like that also show the boys how much more work they have to put into practice and their development to match the top teams in the region. The season before, we played a level lower, the boys beat almost everyone and their egos clearly took off, and the higher league brought them back down to earth a bit. I hope it taught them some humility. But if I had to choose, I don't know anyone who would rather lose. I mention it to show that defeats teach something too, although in general there are not many positives.

Patryk Slomczynski, youth coach at Warta Srem

Girls' soccer deserves a mention here, because the gap between teams is often huge. The problem is that there is often no fix. In some Polish regions, for example, there is only one league for young girls, so girls from small towns who want to play league games have to face the region's strongest clubs, and they stand no chance in a head-to-head game.

I think it is a pointless format, but it is hard to find a better one in girls' leagues, since there is only one. Boys' soccer is very different: there are many groups, and teams can be placed by level so the scores are not so lopsided. Games like that do not have much training value, although you can work on certain things where the score is not the point. That does not work in the long run, because losing 0-10 every week does not build anyone up. I don't think those games teach much, but from my own experience I know we don't have much choice.

Mariola Rebowska, coach of a girls' junior team at UKS Olimp Loczki Wyszkow

We like doing things that make us happy. Unless someone enjoys suffering, but we are not counting on that.

It is hard for soccer to make us happy if all we do is lose and learn nothing. After a while, a person decides the game is pointless and simply quits.

Back to the team that lost 0-22, the second under-19 team at GTS Pruszcz Gdanski. The coach of the club's first under-19 team explained what happened:

Of course, games you lose 0-20 give you nothing. But the team deserves a lot of credit for not falling apart after two defeats like that. They finished the fall season and only now has the team been dissolved. It all started with how the team was put together. That is why they lost so badly: this team did not practice, the players did not meet, and the coach brought them together without a clear purpose. As for scores like that, they clearly make no sense.

Slawomir Ficek

In short, coaches of teams that struggle, or lose badly every week, believe that constant defeats have little or no training value. Does the same apply the other way around, to teams that win by huge margins? We will look at that question in a separate article.

How organizers can avoid lopsided games

At a tournament, you can keep teams of similar strength together. In FC.APP, a two-phase format moves teams into gold, silver and bronze pools based on the first-phase standings, and for the youngest age groups you can play without scores or keep scores and standings hidden from participants. See how FC.APP works for organizers.

Tournaments, scrimmages and player motivation in one app. Free for coaches.

See FC.APP for coaches

See it in FC.APP